Small Business Compliance

Wayfair’s Unintended Consequences: Compliance Challenges for Small Remote Sellers

To mitigate the impact on small remote sellers, the federal Wayfair ruling required states to include a safe harbor provision in their sales tax laws. These provisions are meant to lessen the compliance burden by exempting businesses that fall below certain thresholds—typically based on sales volume or transaction count, like $100,000 in sales or 200 transactions—from the obligation to collect and remit sales tax.

While this was a step in the right direction, the varying safe harbor thresholds and requirements across states have created an overwhelming burden for small remote sellers. They must first determine where they have economic nexus based on the 46 different safe harbor provisions and then navigate the various requirements related to registration, return filings, notice responses, and audits.

Sales tax compliance in this environment is highly complicated, costly, and stressful for small remote sellers. Unlike large corporations with dedicated tax teams, these small businesses often lack the resources to confidently comply with the myriad state tax laws. Many small remote sellers who decide to pursue compliance turn to software solutions and external consultants, while others attempt to handle compliance in-house, often with less favorable outcomes.

Managing Sales Tax Compliance as a Small Business

If you’re a small remote seller, here are a few strategies to manage compliance more effectively:

  1. Evaluate Software Solutions: Look for sales tax software that can automate calculation and reporting to ease (though not replace) the compliance process.

  2. Consult an Expert: A sales tax consultant can help you understand nexus thresholds and manage filings across states, saving time and reducing the risk of errors.

Six years after the Wayfair ruling, challenges for small remote sellers persist. The ruling, while addressing inequities for local businesses, has inadvertently created barriers to small business creation, growth, and entrepreneurial spirit. Non-compliance—whether intentional or unintentional—poses a high risk, and many small sellers are increasingly anxious about potential audits in the coming years.

Need Help Navigating Sales Tax Complexity?
Navigating multi-state compliance can feel overwhelming, but it doesn’t have to be. Reach out to learn more about how I can help simplify sales tax compliance, so you can focus on growing your business.